β¨ Read this awesome post from Hacker News π
π Category:
β Main takeaway:
Joel and Owen peppered me with questions about heat pumps, bad incentives, and why on earth someone would leave rockets for HVAC.
π§ Listen to the full episode
The Question Everyone Asks: βWill a Heat Pump Save Me Money?β
Letβs start with the uncomfortable part.
Owen opened with the question I hear constantly:
βHow do we get the masses to adopt heat pumps when gas is so much cheaper than electricity, especially in California?β
-
Heat pumps really are 3β4x more efficient than gas furnaces.
-
But in much of California, electricity is also 3β4x more expensive than gas.
-
That means the operating costs often come out roughly even, maybe a bit better, maybe a bit worse, depending on the house and rate structure.
I wish I could tell people, βInstall a heat pump and your bills will drop by 50%.β Right now, in most of California, I canβt. And I donβt try to force that narrative.
So instead of pretending thereβs a huge savings where there isnβt, I lean on what is true:
-
You get heating and cooling in one system.
-
Comfort is better and more stable – no more furnace cycling on and off at full blast.
-
Thereβs no combustion, no carbon monoxide risk.
-
With incentives, upfront cost is often lower than installing a traditional AC and furnace.
Is it a financial slam dunk everywhere? No.
Is it a better system that future-proofs the home, often at similar lifetime cost? In most cases, yes.
A Quick Heat Pump Explainer
When I say β3β4x more efficient,β hereβs what I mean in plain terms:
-
A gas furnace is ~80β95% efficient. You burn gas, some energy goes out the flue, the rest warms your home. Youβre creating heat from fuel.
-
A heat pump doesnβt βmakeβ heat; it moves it.
-
Even on a cold day, molecules in the air are movingβthat motion is heat.
-
A heat pump pulls that heat out of the air, concentrates it, and moves it indoors.
-
Itβs the same physics as your refrigerator or air conditioner, just run in reverse in winter.
-
Heat pumps move heat instead of generating it
How I Ended Up Trading Rocket Engines for Heat Pumps
People love to ask how I went from working at companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin to HVAC.
Standing by a Blue Origin lunar lander – I helped design its engine
To be honest, I didnβt wake up one day and ~decide~ to go into heat pumps. It was a winding path, but Iβm grateful I found my way to this space.Β
When I eventually started DMing homeowners on Reddit and Nextdoor asking them, βWhat was your experience getting a heat pump?β, the answers were almost all identical:
-
βItβs really expensive.β
-
βI donβt trust my contractor.β
-
βIβm getting conflicting advice.β
The Bar Is Still So Low
Whatβs wild, and a little sad, is how low the baseline for βgood contractorβ still is.
-
My mom texts four contractors; one replies. Thatβs who gets the job.
-
My in-laws had multiple appointments rescheduled by their solar installer, often with techs showing up hours late.
-
Owen talked about winning a $7M contract basically by just being responsive.
This is part of why I keep saying:
If you want to do something meaningful in climate and have a high tolerance for chaos, start an HVAC company.
Hearing the same frustrations over and over led me to starting my own heat pump company
You donβt need to be the biggest. You just need to show up, do what you say youβre going to do, and care about the quality of your work.
Incentives, the IRA, and Why Some βClimate Moneyβ Backfires
-
People heard for years that huge electrification rebates were coming.
-
Some homeowners delayed critical work, hoping for $8,000+ off a heat pump.
-
In places like Northern California, once funds finally went live, they were gone in a month or two.
So what did we actually achieve?
-
We froze some homeowners in place waiting for programs.
-
We created a huge expectation mismatch.
-
We did not fundamentally change the default equipment being installed.
-
The cost difference between a one-way AC and a heat pump is basically a reversing valve (~$30β$50 in parts).
-
Every major manufacturer already sells both the AC and corresponding heat pump versions of their product.
-
If we subsidized that tiny delta at the manufacturer or distributor level, one-way ACs could just quietly fade out.
Every βnormalβ AC replacement would automatically be a heat pump. Not because the homeowner read a whitepaper, but because thatβs whatβs on the truck.
Perfectionism Is Quietly Killing Decarbonization
-
Air seal and insulate
-
Replace windows
-
Upgrade panel and wiring
-
Maybe, finally, install the heat pump
On a whiteboard, that looks great. In real life:
-
Furnaces die right before a cold snap.
-
People donβt have unlimited capital, bandwidth, or patience.
-
The more steps you stack up front, the more likely they are to say:
βJust put in another gas furnace.β
In California, at least, Iβm very comfortable with electrify first, optimize later:
-
Even leaky, old homes can usually be handled by a modestly sized inverter heat pump.
-
If you upgrade windows and insulation later, the same heat pump just runs at a lower output.
Coming from rocketry, I think in test cycles. You build, test, learn, adjust. If you wait for the perfect model, you never launch anything.
Why Iβm Still Optimistic
We often talk about the ugly in this newsletter – the barriers that are slowing down widespread heat pump adoption. I see a lot of dysfunction up close: bad incentives, messy rates, hilariously low contracting standards.
But hereβs what gives me real hope:
Iβm in a Facebook group with a bunch of small HVAC contractors. Recently someone asked: βWhoβs installing heat pumps these days?β
A couple of years ago, that wouldβve drawn skeptical or hostile replies. This time, Iβd guess 80β90% of the responses were some version of:
-
βWeβre doing a lot of heat pumps now.β
-
βMost of our installs are heat pumps.β
-
βWe only do heat pumps.β
Not from giant, well-branded west coast climate companies. From one- and two-truck shops all over the place.
This is market transformation in action
Thatβs the kind of quiet, unglamorous market shift that actually matters.
So Iβm going to keep doing what Iβve been doing: Talking about heat pumps and installing them.
If any of this nudges one more person to leave the sidelines – whether that means starting a trades business, fixing a broken rate design, or just replacing a dead furnace with a heat pump instead of another gas box – itβs worth it.
π¬ Share your opinion below!
#οΈβ£ #Rockets #Heat #Pumps
π Posted on 1764985398
